Comment Gif

Secret Places

One wet, dreary winter, a friend and I set off to explore the Gulf Islands, which lie in the Strait of Georgia between the British Columbia mainland and Vancouver Island. Stunningly beautiful, and bathed in the mild Pacific climate, we thought the Island lakes might provide a mid-winter’s respite for a couple of frustrated trout fishermen.

We fished a few lakes without success, then found one where big, strong cutthroat trout lay in the deep, dark water. We caught them fishing Muddler Minnows at a near dead drift from a canoe. I remember backpaddling against the slightest breeze, until the line went nearly straight down from the stern of the canoe. A slight pluck, and you struck on a deep line into a big fish.

Of course we were thrilled to be fly fishing in December, but we wondered if the lake produced even better fishing in the spring, or summer. We kept our eyes open for other fly fishermen, hoping local anglers might fill us in. But on our weekend trips we always found the lake empty. It seemed nobody fished the lake except us.

My friend’s uncle wrote an outdoors column for a daily newspaper. And at a family gathering he mentioned to him the great fishing we’d discovered. He was proud to have found a secret place of his own, and wanted to share it with his uncle, who was so widely known and respected in the fishing community.

A few weekends later we went back to the lake - and there were six cars in the parking lot. There were boats on the lake. People were fishing all over the place.

I approached one fisherman who was just coming in, hoping to get some local information about the lake.He told me to fish a Muddler Minnow, on a sinking line, at almost a dead drift.

He’d read about it in the newspaper.

Ever since then I’ve been careful about sharing information about where to fish. Certainly some of my best experiences ever have come when fishermen took me to their secret places.

I’ve written about some of those spots, but I’ve never named them.

I will write about fishing on famous lakes, or about fishing on lakes and rivers where the fishing is good, but not great.

But announcing the names of secret places to the fly fishing world? No thanks. Been there, saw my lake done. Once was enough.

I trust all fly fishermen will understand.

What do you think? Visit our online discussion area and post your views.

Letters can be sent via e-mail to: letters@ariverneversleeps.com

Letters Gif

Hi Mark,

We are in the progress of having local carver Max Chikite do a carving of Roderick Haig-Brown. We think it would be best to have it outside River Sportsman, on the banks of the Campbell River, for security reasons.

Too, I'm starting a fundraising effort to get proper signage. This signage will be at three locations, the Main Island pool, the Sandy Pool and the Line Fence Pool. It will announce the fact that the river is the Haig-Brown Conservation Area and mention the name of the pool.

Also, I'm working on a fundraising effort to restore a summer run of steelhead to the Campbell. The B.C. Ministry of Environment has already captured about 70 fry out of the Tsitika River. They are being reared in Duncan and hopefully we will get good enough pairing to do an egg take. We would like to release them eventually in the Campbell, hopefully working with Norske Skog to access the water out of their pipeline. That way they'll imprint there and won't shoot right into the canyon or up the Quinsam.

Lots of good stuff on the Campbell and for Rod! Hopefully we can get fly only designation as well and then all will be right and good with my home river. Then maybe I can fish it more, work less.

Cheers,

Neil Cameron
Campbell River
British Columbia
neilc@cr.island.net

Hi Neil:
Thanks for dropping us a line on your activities on the Campbell River. For those readers who don’t know, the Campbell was Rod’s home river, and his favorite run of fish, were the summer steelhead. That stocks, sadly, was wiped out by a combination of factors.

A statue of Haig-Brown, and signs to note his pools, is a great tribute to him. But far greater still would be to restore the summer run. The Tsitika has beautiful fish. We look forward to the day when we can cast a Steelhead Bee on the waters of the Campbell, in the summer, with the chance of taking a chrome bright fish.

Any readers would like to financially support Neil’s efforts are urged to contact him.

-Mark Hume


Hi:
I would find it truly helpful to have pictures of types of flys and also their names
Thank you
Wes

Wes Kowalchuk
Strome, Alberta
wesco@telusplanet.net

Hi Wes
Have you looked at the bottom of FlyBox page? http://www.ariverneversleeps.com/fishingbc/flybox.shtml
We have a list of favorite BC Fly's there.

-Rgds,
Nick Didlick


The Editors:
Another great issue.I do find somethings disturbing though.You claim to be an internet magazine for flyfishers, yet you publish articles about spoon fishing and a club that promotes and has helped decimate the large genetics from a race of salmon. I would hope that most flyfishers practice catch & release and would not particpate in a club thats requirements for joining is killing a large fish. Thank you for allowing me to vent.

Troy Peters
Terrace Canada
steelheadtroy@aol.com


Hi Troy:
Thanks for your note. First let me disagree with your point that the article about the Tyee Club doesn't belong on A River Never Sleeps. True, it isn't about fly fishing, but I think the vast majority of fly fishermen would find the history of the Tyee Club fascinating. And I know that any fisherman, even a dedicated fly fisherman, would enjoy trolling the Tyee grounds, in a row boat. I loved Van Egan's story, and I knew others would enjoy it too - and that's why we posted it.

You make another, more important point, with which I fully agree. And that is that the Tyee Club must share some of the blame for the decline of the Campbell River's great run of chinook. Killing all those big salmon - and selecting only the biggest, in the style of trophy hunters - surely removed some of the very best genetic material from the mix. Significant as that damage may have been, it pales in comparison to the impact of the mine, dam and commercial fishing. That notwithstanding, I do feel the Tyee Club should be doing more to protect the salmon they love.

Understandably, the club is proud of its long history....but why not find a way to embrace catch-and-release fishing? Surely we could trust the boat guides to do on-water estimates of the size of a catch, and then to release the fish. In New Zealand, marlin fishermen release much bigger trophies - and they signal their great catches by flying flags from their mastheads. It's a stirring sight to see the boats coming back from the fishing grounds, with their flags high, knowing that each bright piece of fabric signals another fish released.

-Sincerely,
Mark Hume


Hi Mark,
Just a note that Campbell River council just proclaimed the Campbell, from bank to bank, estuary to Elk Falls, the Haig-Brown Conservation Area. It took a year but it went through unanimously. Also, a local group is working on a Haig-Brown festival which shall be an annual event.

It took 25 years after his death, but the municipality that owes its world renown to the man, finally recognized him.

Cheers,
Neil Cameron
Campbell River, British Columbia
neilc@cr.island.net

Neil;
Great news. Thanks for letting us know. Now, how about working on the city leaders to put up a statue of him, with his fly rod, on the banks of the Campbell?
-Cheers,
Mark


{E-mail letters may be edited for clarity, taste and brevity. It is understood they express the opinions of the writers, not the editors.}